topleft
topright

 

It's good in parts!

 

An anatomical anthology of Mark's body of work, from the Liberian President's ears to Al Gore's calves
Mark Steyn From Head To Toe
Order your autographed copy exclusively from
The Steyn Store

 

My Sharia Amour
Hot enough
for gulf emirs...

You gotta start off each day with a song and a great cup of coffee! And our exclusive mug brings out the romantic in every jihadist:
The My Sharia Amour
gift pack

Order yours exclusively from
The Steyn Store

 
Steyn on Britain and Europe
OUT OF DUTCH Print E-mail
Tuesday, 16 March 2010

These aren't words one has cause to type terribly often, but I think Charles Krauthammer is being deeply naïve in his observations on Geert Wilders (as, reportedly, was Glenn Beck, to whom I am otherwise well disposed, not least because he liked my Christmas single).

Wilders does not need to be lectured condescendingly about distinctions within Islam, because he lives with them every day. And he has concluded, notwithstanding Dr. Krauthammer's views on the precise "minority" that identifies as "Islamist," that Islam itself is the issue — and that, therefore, regardless of the "moderation" of the "overwhelming majority" of Muslims, the more Islam the less Netherlands in any recognizable sense. Are the gangs of gay bashers on the streets of Amsterdam "Islamist" by Krauthammer's definition? Maybe, maybe not. But, either way, they make the running, and the rest of the community is either indifferent or quiescent.

As for whether Wilders is "extremist," his views on the cultural compatibility of immigrants were routine and unexceptional until the 1960s, not only in Europe, but also in the U.S. And, even in North America today, they are the stated policy of the Government of Quebec. One can certainly disagree with that, but does that make Quebec also "fascist" (Beck) or even "extreme" (Krauthammer)?

Dr. Krauthammer is also incorrect to suggest there are two issues here. When the state attempts to constrain further Europe's already too shriveled bounds of public discourse, the only issue is state power. The Continental political class does not want to debate the question of its ever more assertive Muslim populations, and so has decided to criminalize that debate. Geert Wilders lives under 24/7 security because Muslims (including the killer of Theo van Gogh) have pledged to murder him. Yet he's the one on trial for incitement? The issue is not Wilders or his views, but the Dutch state and their ever more "extreme, radical, and wrong" views on core Western liberties.

National Review's The Corner, March 9th 2010

 

MARK'S MOST WANTED

SteynOnline's highest-rated programming of the month

1 (-) THE SEDUCTIONS OF DECLINE
Steyn on America

2 (2) THE AUDACITY OF DULL
One Year Ago

3 (3) THE ROUTINE OF THE EXTREME
Happy Warrior

4 (-) CARRIED AWAY
Happy Warrior

5 (-) EXITS AND STRATEGIES
Ave atque vale

6 (6) BEWARE OF THE GUANOKHAZI
Happy Warrior

7 (-) COLD WAR ON ICE
Topical Take

8 (-) PLAYING GRUFF
Steyn on Screen

9 (7) THE PEDOPHILE SANTA OF GLOBAL CAPITALISM
One Year Ago

10 (-) CLEAN SWEEP FOR THE NEW BROOMS
Topical Take

ONE HARDBACK!
TWO HATEMONGERS!

aa paperback medium.jpg 

The new book by Ezra Levant with a special introduction by Steyn

Shakedown
Ezra takes you behind the scenes in the Danish cartoons case, the Steyn/Maclean's case, and the Canadian state's war on free speech and real human rights.
Order your copy personally autographed by Mark exclusively from
The Steyn Store

Got a comment on a column? Drop a line to Mark's Mailbox

© 2010 SteynOnline

Joomla Template by Joomlashack
Joomla Templates by JoomlaShack Joomla Templates