The nearest thing to a Golden Age star at this year's Oscars was Kim Novak, and her appearance set Twitter a-flutter, and not in a good way. I prefer to remember her the way she was when I, very briefly, met her, at the time of her last movie, Mike Figgis' Liebestraume (1991). She was a beautiful middle-aged woman then, but she didn't enjoy the experience, and so it proved to be her final film. More of a distant vision of a star than the real thing, Miss Novak gave two good performances in two very different Sinatra films (The Man With The Golden Arm and Pal Joey*), and one other role ensured that she will last as long as movies do. Vera Miles had originally been cast in the part of Judy/Madeleine - a dark-haired shop girl playing a fair-haired trophy wife. But Miss Miles got pregnant, and Alfred Hitchcock insisted the studio sign Kim Novak. Two years ago, in a British Film Institute poll, Vertigo was voted the best picture of all time, which seems a stretch to me. I'm not even sure it's Alfred Hitchcock's best. But it's certainly Miss Novak's:
Gorgeously restored and digitally remastered, Vertigo these days looks better than it did on its release 56 years ago - especially all those wacky signature effects: the spiral motif, symbolizing the psychological vortex of the film; the vertigo effect itself, created by zooming forward and tracking back simultaneously on a miniature set, so that the stairwell itself seems to uncoil and then compress; and, of course, Hitchcock's camera gliding in and out, slowly, slowly, slowly - memorably spoofed, like everything else in Vertigo, in Mel Brooks's High Anxiety, where the camera tracks in too far and bumps into the window.
Vertigo opens on the rooftops of San Francisco, where Scottie, played by James Stewart, is in hot pursuit of a villain. A police colleague comes to his aid, but Scottie can only hang helpless from the building's edge as his fellow officer plunges to his death. Diagnosed with vertigo, Scottie quits the force and reluctantly takes a job trailing an old school pal's wife, whom the husband insists has been possessed by a suicidal ancestor. When Madeleine does, indeed, kill herself, by diving from a bell tower he's too scared to climb, Scottie is consumed by guilt and suffers a nervous breakdown. At which point, he runs into a remarkably similar-looking woman and gets obsessed all over again, determined to discover the link, as the film's original trailer put it, "between the golden girl in the dark tower and the tawdry redhead he tried to remake in her image".
The link isn't that tricky to figure out. At their first meeting, Judy, the tawdry redhead, has a flashback, and we learn the truth about what happened in the dark tower. The whodunnit is a side-show, which is why Hitchcock throws it away halfway through; for this film, he's motoring on pure psychology. As in so much of his work - not least Psycho - Vertigo is about obsession and the loss of identity. But Vertigo is Hitchcock's Hitchcock - literally: an autobiographical exploration of his own particular obsession. As Scottie, Stewart gives an unusually intense, overwrought performance, and, as if to compensate, almost everything else in the picture is cooled down. Watch that first scene between Stewart and his gal pal Barbara Bel Geddes (Miss Ellie from "Dallas'). The dialogue's very even, very modulated, like two old friends hanging around on a lazy afternoon: it's so good you hardly notice it, but rarely in movies do you get such a good strong sense of two people who know each other that well. They have a brief conversation about brassieres, and, in those three or four lines, you learn everything about their relationship. Conversely, after Scottie has fished the suicidal Madeleine out of San Francisco Bay, taken her home and put her to bed, you're aware - and she's aware, and he's aware that she's aware - that he's seen her naked. That fact cuts through everything else in the scene. And that it's Jimmy Stewart who's seen her naked makes it even more palpable.
Vertigo fulfills that boast which so many films aim for but so few exemplify: it really does go beyond words. For large chunks of the picture there seems to be no dialogue at all - instead, Scottie and Madeleine wander around as if their strange trance-like relationship has already passed beyond words: the emotions are articulated by Bernard Herrmann's omnipresent score. When Madeleine dies and Scottie meets the tawdry redhead, we're suddenly back to dialogue, for this is a more prosaic, earthbound relationship:
"Judy, you don't understand..."
"Oh, I understand alright. I've been understanding since I was 17."
This is the film's central performance. Hitchcock was famously fond of cool blondes - Grace Kelly, Eva Marie Saint - but Vertigo is the only film where he deconstructs his obsession: Stewart's Scottie is a Hitchcockian male, a Professor Higgins determined to rebuild Judy, his soiled little shop girl, into the austere, icy blonde Madeleine of his dreams. What makes the double-role work brilliantly is Kim Novak. She wasn't too experienced an actress back then, and she brings an artlessness to the performance that is just right. In the first half of the picture, when she's ambling around in a flat-voiced trance, you can't quite put your finger on what's wrong; but, of course, it's that her acting isn't that good - which is entirely appropriate when we subsequently meet her as the tawdry redhead. It also helps that Miss Novak was kind of big and lumpy (not afterwards - she looked fabulous round the time of Liebestraume), so she seems, even as she's all dolled up as one of San Francisco's finest ladies, as if she's not quite at ease.
Hitchcock was acknowledging the futility of his fantasies: a "woman of mystery" - enigmatic, few words - is a woman who's fine for a mystery but can't keep it up forever; the moment you get to know her, the spell is broken. He believed that every beautiful woman is a deception, and it prompted in him a sort of sensual equivalent to his vertigo effect - simultaneously drawn in and repelled. "Why are you doing this?" asks Novak, as Stewart demands she assume the dead woman's hair and clothes. "What good will it do?"
"I don't know," he says. "No good, I guess. I don't know..."
He reaches to caress her face but then pulls away. It's a superb moment from James Stewart and, in that one gesture, he distills brilliantly Hitchcock's entire approach to his leading ladies.
[*apologies for original error]
Comment on this item (members only)
Viewing and submission of reader comments is restricted to Mark Steyn Club members only. If you are not yet a member, please click here to join. If you are already a member, please log in here: